Four interviews were conducted with parents of children varying age.
Links to interview questions follow below.
Did your child use a transitional object?
When did your child begin using a transitional object?
How old was your child when he/she stopped using a transitional object?
When or what part of the day did your child use the object the most?
How often did your child use the object?
In your opinion, why did your child use the object?
Did you have any restrictions regarding use of the object?
How did you seperate your child from the object?
In your opinion, when is a child too old to use an object?
Did you have any concerns about your child using a transitional object?
Did your child use a transitional object?Amy is a 6 year-old who sucked her thumb.
Matt is a 4 month-old who currently uses a pacifier.
Tim is a 4 year-old who uses a stuffed Mickey Mouse as a favorite object.
Jordan is a 3 year-old who uses a soft blanket object.
When did your child begin using a transitional object?
Amy began sucking her thumb at birth.
Matt has used a pacifier since birth but only sometimes, "on and off". Just today started sucking on his thumb, but would suck on fingers/fist too.
Tim only began using his Mickey Mouse toy about six months ago, so it really can not qualify as a transitional object.
Jordan began using her blanket when she was about 6 months in age. It was then that we noticed she liked to be near the blanket, especially when she was distressed.
How old was your child when he/she stopped using a transitional object?
Amy stopped sucking her thumb when she was age 4.
Not applicable because Matt is still using his pacifier.
Not applicable because Tim does not rely on the object for security.
Jordan is still using her blanket.
When or what part of the day did your child use the object the most?
Amy sucked her thumb during the quiet times of day; nap time, watching cartoons etc.
Matt sucks more when laying by himself, when mother puts him down to play with toys alone. He still sucks when mother holds him but not as much unless he is hungry. Sucking usually is a "automatic" sign of hunger for Matt.
Tim likes to have his toy when he sleeps.
Jordan likes her blanket when she watches television, goes to bed or quietly plays. I also let her take it along when I need to run a list of errands. The blanket helps to keep her occupied.
How often did your child use the object?
Amy would only suck her thumb if she was holding a soft diaper. I was able to control thumbsucking with use of diaper. I would restrict where the diaper would go.
"Matt uses his pacifier a lot. Maybe 10 to 12 times per day." Mother is not concerned about the frequency or need for a pacifier.
Tim only uses his toy when he goes to bed.
Jordan uses her blanket frequently.
In your opinion, why did your child use the object?
Amy used thumbsucking as a comfort thing.
Mother feels that Matt uses his pacifier to soothe himself and he "enjoys it".
Tim expressed that he liked Mickey Mouse after watching a cartoon. He then asked for the toy after he saw the cartoon.
I think Jordan uses her blanket because it is quite soft to the touch. I think it is something familiar to her too.
Did you have any restrictions regarding use of the object?
Amy carried around a soft diaper whenever she sucked her thumb. I could control her thumbsucking by removing the diaper. At 2 1/2 I only allowed Amy to carry the diaper at home. When she was 4, she was only allowed to have the diaper during bedtime. Eventually, I took the diaper away.
Matt is not restricted on the use of his pacifier. Parents will take it away when it seems like he doesn't want it or he "spits it out". They usually just give it to him "whenever" but especially when he whimpers/fusses a little and she knows it isn't a dirty diaper, or hunger.
Tim does not carry the object during the day, so we do not need to restrict the use of the object.
I haven't had any restrictions on Jordan's blanket use, yet! Eventually, I think we need to come up with a plan to discourage Jordan from taking the blanket with her and using it so often.
How did you seperate your child from the object?
I just took the diaper away from Amy. I told her that she was a big girl now and could do without it.
Not applicable because Matt is still using his pacifier.
Tim seems to not be to attached to the toy. My spouse breast-feeded Tim until his was 3. Tim still co-sleeps with my spouse and I now. It seems to help Tim to not have fear and insecurity.
Jordan has not been seperated from her blanket yet.
In your opinion, when is a child too old to use an object?
I think that after 2 is too old for pacifiers. Parents have more control over an object rather than a thumb. Pacifiers are a parents' way of calming the child rather letting the child calm themselves. After 3 is too old for thumbsucking, because you must wean them off. A child constantly has their thumb with them.
Mother thought that they might try to wean Matt off a bit at 6 months if needed or possible. Not really sure if there was an age that she was thought that was too old to be using a pacifier.
No response to this question.
This is a hard question to answer. I think it is easier with pacifiers. I am sure that it is time to start weaning Jordan off of taking her blanket places. I think it depends on the child.
Did you have any concerns about your child using a transitional object?
My only concern with Amy was dental problems. As it turns out, she has the straightest teeth of all my children.
Matt is still an infant, but mother was very curious about how to eventually wean him from the pacifier and if they should restrict his use of it.
Co-sleeping with children is popular phenomenon in Asian counties. We, parents, are concerned about the security of our children when they wake up during sleeping time. The other reason might be due to limited living space and no air conditioning equipment. That means my spouse and I must sacrifice our privacy, but the result is my kids don't like to carry objects the whole day. They believe that we will be there when they need us.
So far I think Jordan has benefitted from her blanket. My only concern is when and how to get her to depend on her blanket less.